THE REASON
UNDERNEATH THE REALITY
INTRODUCTION
The title of my homily for this 5th Tuesday in
Ordinary Time is, “The Reason Underneath the Reality.”
One of the most important rules in life is to question
the reason behind a law - or a rule or a regulation.
St, Thomas Aquinas would say, “Authority is the weakest
argument.” In other words, it’s not, “Who
said so?” but “Why do you say so?”
We often don’t ask because we might labeled a pain if we
do.
I know I don’t like to be questioned on some things, because I’m not the boss and
I realize I can’t do anything about lots
of things - especially in the Catholic Church. For example some marriage
legislation, etc.
TODAY’S GOSPEL
The title of my homily is, “The Reason Underneath the
Reality.”
I don’t know if that’s a message from today’s gospel, but
that’s one issue that hit me.
Today’s gospel has Jesus being quite critical of the
Pharisees - and their practices - and dare we say, “One of the reasons they
wanted Jesus dead was right here.” He
was going after them for all these washing rules they were pushing.
Of course, it’s important to wash one’s hands - especially
during the flu season.
We want those who work in restaurants to wash their hands
after going to the bathroom. I saw that sign in a Burger King bathroom the
other night - and I said, “Good!”
So washing jugs and kettles and hands is important.
However, if folks become extremists - then maybe enough’s
enough.
Is that the point we’re being asked to consider. If the Pharisees
amongst us attack those of us who don’t
take everything so totally serious - that we aren’t living up to their
standards. Are they then trying to make
the rest of us look dirty and make themselves look so clean?
I don’t know. I assume we know a lot more about
cleanliness today than back in Jesus’ time. So maybe they were onto
something. I don’t know.
WHERE I WOULD
GO WITH RULES AND REGULATIONS
I remember seeing a documentary about strip mining in
Kentucky.
Coal miners - and coal companies - in the short run found
it too expensive to live up to all the environmental safety regulations - so it
was much cheaper to pay the fines. They
were saving money and making more money and keeping afloat. Then what happened was run off - because trees
were not replanted after strip mining and soil, water, were ruined downstream
and down into the valleys. Then there
were big time health problems.
There’s a dilemma that is always there.
The title of my homily is, “The Reason Underneath the
Reality.”
I assume the rules for washing hands started off for the
right reason, but in time it became an extreme and people were doing it as an
extreme - and then they rubbed it in and were saying, “We’re better than you.”
There’s the Pharisees in today’s gospel avoiding helping
their parents financially in their old age, by putting their money into a fund
called korban.
W.C. Fields in some movie had a Bible in hand and was
paging through it and he says, “Just looking for loopholes. Just looking for
loopholes.
I would assume the maintenance of parents is more
important than donating for maintenance of St. Mary’s and St. John Neumann
churches.
I would assume
that the trick is to study all this - ask questions - ask reasons - and then make sure the reasons below the
surface are good ones.
If they are pride,
selfishness, and to feel cleaner than others, then pause and recalculate our motives and
behavior.
CONCLUSION
So obviously in life we need to ask questions. We have to do our homework. We need to be humble and honest.